CAT 2014 Analysis: November 22, Slot-2

It has been a while since there was no sectional time-limit and since I barely take any full-length mocks CATs apart from the actual CAT, it was a pleasant departure from the previous attempts.

So, let’s dig in to the analysis in the order I attempted the paper.

Verbal Ability
Wanted to really max this section so started with VA and specifically RCs. The four RCs were all relatively straightforward. If we want to split hairs, we can classify two as Easy and two as Moderate; compared to SimCATs they can only be classified as tame. Also for the first time in a quite a few years I felt there were no ambiguous options. During the Prometric years, I often left some RC questions purely because I knew none of the four options were correct and I did not want to both lose a mark and dignify the question with an answer (I was setting the Verbal Sections of the IMS SimCATs for a while, so I know a thing or two about question-setting)

Only on 2 out of the 16 questions did two options seem close and even on those a re-check would easily lead one to the answer. For those whose strong suit is Verbal, the RCs were a nicely-wrapped gift. For those who are of average ability with RCs, 3 passages with 10-12 attempts and 8-10 correct was definitely possible. I would say about 25 marks from RC were there for the taking.

Moved on to VA which was also surprisingly harmless. None of the question types posed any real problem. If we were to arrange the question-types in increasing order of difficulty they would be Jumbled Paragraphs, Grammar, Odd One Out, CR-Summary, CR-Inference. Everyone who prepared for the test could have attempted 12 questions.

The bulk of the scoring in this section should have come from VA & RC with 20-25 attempts and 18-22 questions correct.

Logical Reasoning
Since I had made sufficient attempts in VA-RC in good time to clear the sectional cut-offs I was only looking at LR as an added bonus to push the overall score higher. But it did not turn out to be that easy. One set was easy, two were moderate and one was tough. Even on the moderate sets, 1-2 questions should have been left in each set as they were time-consuming.

For those for whom LR is the main scoring area around 10-12 questions attempted across 3 sets would have been the best they could have done.

So, without getting into the percentile nitty-gritty, what is a good number of attempts on this section? For those with strong QA-DI, around 28-32 good attempts were definitely possible, for those who were looking to this section to max their overall score through the VA-LR section, around 32-36 attempts.

Quantitative Ability & Data Interpretation
QA was a pleasant surprise since despite all news pointing towards an easy QA on previous slots, one does not believe it until one sees it, the questions were as straight-forward as they can come. The only thing that could go against you were silly mistakes. Those who attended all classes and were aware of the basic stuff would have had no problem with the QA.

DI was a bit tricky and time-consuming and if one devoted bulk of the time to QA then just picking one DI set would have sufficed.

Overall for someone looking to max their score through this section around 33-38 questions were definitely possible; for those who are average on QA-DI around 25-32 attempts were a definite possibility.

I think this year’s CAT had a larger purpose than just screening students for the second stage. The papers this year send out a signal that the IIMs, especially the newer ones, do not want students to shy away from the test because of its perceived toughness. The QA section was made easier so that more non-engineers would be encouraged to take up the test, and the VA section was definitely not scary for engineers.

Whether the test is tough or easy, it does not make a difference to the selection procedure of the IIMs since they use percentiles. But managing the perception of the test is paramount to ensure that slew of new IIMs that have been launched do not have empty seats!

By the way, the CAT is over but the test-taking season is not over yet. For those whose CAT did not go that well, there still are plenty more fish in the sea, especially one called XAT, which is on par or better than few of the older IIMs. For those who did well, it is still a job half done, so do not give yourself a break of more than 2-3 days. So either ways it time to put the CAT behind us and get back to prepping for the rest of the tests!

All the best!

T.

8 thoughts on “CAT 2014 Analysis: November 22, Slot-2

  1. Dear T, I’m really glad that you took the test is the same slot as mine. What percentile could I expect with the raw score of around 150-180. I know this is just a prediction. But a rough estimate would help me apply to the right colleges.

    Regards,
    Adithi

    • Hi Adithi,
      Firstly, if you are expecting that score range, you have done well in the test :-). your percentile could be in the 97-99+ range for the score range you have given.
      Lets hope for the best,
      T.

  2. Sir , I have attempted 66+ (“+ bcoz 3 or 4 might have appeared in markd for review”).
    I could not prepare specifically for CAT but with enough confidence in my abilities I gave a sincere attempt .I can assure dat I did not do any guess work .
    I wrote a couple of mocks before where i score 84-85 %ile but I think in the exam I did much better .
    But I am unable to predict even the rough range of possible score or percentile . So with the average no of correct attempts what could my percentile range ..PLZ help me .
    Also as the application dates of some good institutes close much before CAT result, kindly let me know if I can apply to NITIE..?

    • Prediction is very difficult. I would suggest, for now, you use your Sim percentiles as a (very rough) guide, scores will change wildly depending on test difficulty, but percentiles not so much.

      Many colleges ensure that their deadlines are before the results (and often even before the test, in some cases) so that anyone who is reasanobly hopeful will go ahead and apply. After the scores are out, a lot of people will find that they hadn’t done as well as they’d thought, and so won’t apply! There’s nothing much you can do about that; it is a perfectly logical and legal strategy, though perhaps of dubious morality from a student’s point of view.

      What you need to do is ask yourself whether you want to go to that college. In this case, if you want to do Operations, apply by all means. If you are not certain that you want a career in Ops, better not. The choice has to be yours.

      regards
      J

  3. Hello J n T sir,

    Probably a bit late at the party… but nevertheless would have been grave injustice on my part to not visit this again. One of my sweetest achievements in life has been to follow this blog which to be honest never felt like exam prep blog. I followed this blog because i loved being here.. Irrespective of what results throw up.. it is because of this blog that my cat journey was so memorable… and in this journey i learned so much that words fall short. I also thank J sir for the way he made me realize my mistake through his presentation at a seminar. I was always took test with mindset with doing 60 questions and was not even successful in that. But after the presentation i completed 65 q in sim15 and 75 in actual cat .. i dont know about the accuracy in verbal as va questions were vocab-less(only inference,summary,grammar,parajumbles) and thereby confusing.. but it was a welcome change from the nervous breakdown i suffered last year at the test. I will be back on results day.. Thank you CATHOLICS… you ppl inspire me to not just do well in cat but be a good teacher in the unforeseeable future..

    • Hi Girish,
      Thanks a lot for the generous words Girish. You have made a good number of attempts, hope the percentile turns out right. Waiting for the results day like you and the rest the test-takers.
      All the best,
      T.

  4. Awesome site you have here but I was wanting to know if you knew of any user
    discussion forums that cover the same topics discussed here?
    I’d really love to be a part of online community where I can get feed-back from other experienced people that share the same interest.
    If you have any recommendations, please let me know. Thank you!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s